Pay My Bill

It’s secure. It’s easy. It’s convenient.

Remembering to pay your premiums on time just got easier! You’ll be able to schedule recurring payments, make one-time payments, or pay through our automated phone pay system at 866-285-2979.


DOXO is a third-party online bill payment website that allows users to pay their premium online through their website. They are not affiliated in any way with New Mexico Mutual.

Their website gives the impression that they are affiliated with New Mexico Mutual, but they are not. Users who process payments through DOXO may be charged extra fees. New Mexico Mutual has no control over when DOXO premium payments are mailed to us, possibly resulting in a late payment fee or cancellation due to non-payment.

We recommend that our customers only use the bill payment option found on our website for online or pay by phone, there are no extra fees for this service.

Pay online at
Pay by phone 866-285-2979.

Doxo website warning screenshot


Please contact us at (505) 343-7744 or